Refi Roadmap: A Locked Rate Isn’t a Closed Loan

Here is a great article on what you should know when doing a home loan refinance  -Keane

 

By Julian Hebron

 

Rates are bouncing around near record lows set last October and consumers are looking to seize the opportunity. There’s always a rush by consumers and loan agents to lock rates on dips, and that practice is all the more prevalent when extreme daily rate swings raise the sense of urgency.

 

But before you take the ready-fire-aim approach, remember the old saying: haste makes waste. Just because a rate is locked doesn’t mean the loan will close. Here’s how you can make sure that it does.

 

Let Lender Run Your Credit Score: Credit bureau scoring models know people shop for mortgages, so more than one mortgage-related credit run in a 30 day window won’t reduce your score. Many critical loan approval factors are built into a credit report, so a lender should run your credit before the rate lock—even if you’ve worked with that lender before. Your rate is predicated on the credit score, and scores fluctuate daily as you use credit cards. Credit reports also show current balances on housing and all other debt, and these balances can impact qualifying. Credit reports also show any derogatory items on your credit history, including recent creditor mistakes you may not know about—these are common, and you’re guilty of creditor mistakes until you prove you’re innocent. Most lenders can help here, but it takes time so running credit should be first in the process.

 

Tell Lender About Job, Income, Asset Changes: If you’re working with a lender for the first time, of course you must provide a full financial profile along with paystubs, tax returns and bank statements to back it up. But if you’re working with a lender you’ve already worked with, never assume the documentation process is any different. Tell them everything when you talk about rates. Have you changed jobs or titles? Did you not get your bonus this year? Or was it bigger? Did you spend all your savings on a vacation or new car? Or will you in the next 60 days? All banks approve loans based on your debt-to-income ratio, and these factors all go into the calculation. The debt comes from the credit report and tax returns, and the income comes from paystubs, tax returns and bank statements.

 

Provide All Documentation Immediately: Provide this documentation right away even if a busy loan agent doesn’t ask for it right away. The only exception to this rule is if the loan agent explicitly tells you they’re doing a special refinance that doesn’t require documentation because of some certain bank or government program.

 

Your Property Must Qualify: It’s not enough for your credit score and debt-to-income ratio to qualify you. The property must also qualify. First, there must be enough equity in your home. Due to appraisal rules that prevent loan agents from pre-screening home values with appraisers, you usually have to pay for an appraisal up front to find out if you have sufficient equity. Second, the lender may require any big deferred maintenance issues like rotting wood, chipping paint, water damage or signs of water damage to be fixed before the loan closes—this is another timing issue that affects rate locks, so tell your lender if you have maintenance issues. And if you’re in a condo, the condo building must have at least 51% owner-occupancy, a healthy budget with no (or at least well-explained and documented) special assessments, no litigation, no single owner holding more than 10% of units, and no more than 20% commercial space (or 25% for FHA).

 

Don’t Forget Your Second Mortgage!: If you have a second mortgage, the second mortgage holder must agree to ‘subordinate’ behind a new first mortgage before the new mortgage can close. Whether or not the second mortgage is with the lender handling the refi, this subortination review and approval adds time to the process, sometimes weeks. As such, see ‘Is Your Rate Locked For Long Enough’ below. And zero-balance Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCs) follow these same rules. Even if there’s a zero balance, the HELOC holder must approve the subordination.

 

Incorrect Loan Balances Blow Rate Locks:  Setting your refi loan amount is related to credit reports and the ‘Cost Or No-Cost Refinance’ section below. Your credit report will show your existing loan balance, and if you choose a refi with closing costs, you need to choose whether you’re paying cash or adding costs to the new loan. If loan agents are locking rates too quickly, here are a couple ways it can blow up the process: (1) they forget to account for existing loan payments you just made or will make during the refi process, then they find out when you’re signing final papers and you have to restart—which can blow your rate lock, or (2) they assume your property will appraise for a certain amount and if your value comes in low, they have to redo the loan amount—which can cause you to have a higher rate or fees, or you might have to pay your loan down in order to qualify.

 

Cost or No-Cost Refinance?: If you think rates will drop more, it’s best to do a no-cost refinance so that you can refinance again later without having fees wash out the lower-rate benefit. If you think rates are as low as they can go, it’s best to do a refinance with normal fees ($2500-4500 depending on your market) and perhaps ‘buy your rate down’ by paying tax deductible points (a ‘point’ is 1% of your loan amount). On a no-cost transaction, lenders offset your closing costs by offering a slightly higher rate, usually .125% to .25% higher.

 

What Is The Rate Outlook?: The U.S. and global economies are in uncharted territory given mass post-crisis government stimulus spending, so even the best market oracles don’t know how rates will play. But here’s what we do know: rates drop when mortgage backed securities (MBS) rise, and MBS are at all-time highs because they’re one of the best safe havens for global investors rattled by market uncertainty. This is why rates are at record lows. MBS are priced for a very weak economic outlook. Any signs of improvement will cause MBS to sell and rates to rise.

 

Getting Rate Quotes: Even the best rate websites like MortgageNewsDaily aren’t a substitute for a rate quote. As noted in the ‘Cost or No-Cost’ section, there’s a direct relationship between rates and fees, so a rate quote will depend on your objectives and it can only be provided to you by a lender. Always insist on a full written term sheet displaying the rate, term (e.g., 30yr fixed), every single line item closing cost, total monthly costs including insurance and taxes, and total cash-to-close or cash-in-hand at closing. Lenders are required by Federal law to give you a three-page Good Faith Estimate but this form is a joke because it doesn’t show you all of your line items, nor your total monthly cost, nor your cash-to-close. So make sure your lender shows this to you in some written format before you lock a rate.

 

Is Your Rate Locked For Long Enough?: Banks are busy during these rate dips and quoted rates can only be locked for a certain number of days. Ask your loan agent when they expect to close your loan, and if their quoted rate lock is enough time to get the deal done. Also refer back to the ‘Provide All Documentation Immediately’ section above, so you can hold the loan agent’s feet to the fire if the delays are on their end and not yours.

 

Your Rate vs. Headline Rates: Every Thursday Freddie Mac publishes a rate survey from the previous week. This is source material for virtually all media. In addition to the fact that those rates are expired by the time you’re reading about them, there’s lots of fine print the headlines don’t catch including: those rates are only for loans to $417k, single family homes only, owner-occupied only, and most of those loans have .7% to .8% in points (aka extra fees). Rates on this website are more timely, but again, a rate quote is based on your profile and your property profile so it must come from a lender to be specific.

 

What If Rates Drop More During Loan Process: When you lock a rate, you’re setting that rate then the market will go up or down. It’s very much like buying a stock. The main difference is that lenders have what they call ‘renegotiation’ policies if rates drop after you’ve locked. All renegotiation policies are similar in that rates have to drop significantly for you to be able to capture some of that drop after you’ve already locked a rate. Bottom line: renegotiations don’t let you capture the entire gain because you’ve already made a commitment. So as an example, if you locked a rate at 4.75% and the quoted rate for that same unlocked loan a week later dropped to 4.5%, most lender renegotiation policies will give you half of the gain which would put you at 4.625%.

 

Julian Hebron is San Francisco branch manager and a top producer for RPM Mortgage and also runs mortgage and housing blog The Basis Point.

How Does Fannie Mae’s and Freddie Mac’s Downgrade in Rating Impact Rates?

On August 8th 2011, S&P downgraded Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac from a AAA rating to a AA+ rating. When a security’s rating drops, it often indicates that the investment is less desirable resulting in higher rates. That is not the case this time around.

The US Government has been supporting Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac since 2008. The downgraded rating is result in a downgrade in all US backed debt. Although the rating is lower, investors know this is a sign of slow economic growth in the US, not an isolated hit on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Since then, investors have flooded their money out of the stock market into safer investments with surging prices  in commodities, such as gold, as well as long term bonds including Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac backed securities. The result, lower mortgage rates.

It may seem odd that investors are buying a security immediately after its rating was lowered, but that’s exactly what’s happening. Mortgage securities backed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are reaching their highest prices of the year leading to a drop in mortgage rates.

USDA Loans to Implement Annual Fee…is VA Next?

For years, the US Department of Agriculture has insured home loans for qualified buyers with zero-down, affordable home loans.  Even though the qualifications were very different, these loans functionally looked a lot like VA loans for veterans, providing zero-down loans with no mortgage insurance and low interest rates.

Starting October 1st, 2011, the USDA will be implementing an annual fee which is very similar to a mortgage insurance premium.  This fee will be added to the homeowners monthly payment.  The USDA will still allow the client to buy with no money down.  Similarly to FHA loans, this is due to the increased demand for USDA loans since the market has heavily relied on government-backed home loans.

Between 2006 and 2010, FHA had increased their market share more than 500% going from 3.77% to 19.13%.  In 2010, the USDA also had seen a large increase in market share and temporarily suspended insuring home loans due to limited funding.

The only government-insured home loan that has not seen an increase is VA loans (loans for qualified military veterans), but don’t be surprised if we see one.  As more troops return from Afghanistan and Iraq, more veterans are using their VA loan entitlement to purchase a home.  I’m sure the VA would like to see the program continue under it’s current terms but if they begin to run out of funds, they’ll have no choice to but to raise the premium for VA loans by charging more.

UPDATED 9/19/2011

I’m happy to announce the VA is changing their fees, but for less!  This both surprising and welcomed.  The VA announced on Sept. 8th, 2011 (Circular 26-11-12) that the VA will temporarily change their Funding Fees effective October 1st.  The change lowers the fee for most scenarios.

Below is a chart showing the changes effective Oct. 1st, 2011.  You’ll notice the only two scenarios that do not result in a reduced Funding Fee is when the transaction is a VA-to-VA loan transaction.

 

How Do Buy A New House When You’re Underwater

One of the biggest problems with the housing market is helping homeowners move when they’re underwater.  Whether it’s a job relocation or an addition to the family, many of us find that our current home doesn’t fit our needs anymore.  Most people feel they have no options when they owe more than their house is worth.  In this post, I’m going to dive into multiple options with an emphasis on an option that many homeowners may not think is available to them.  Please note that hardship options, such as foreclosure, short sales and deed in lieu of foreclosure are not discussed here.

Continue reading How Do Buy A New House When You’re Underwater

How Will the Government Shut Down Affect the Mortgage Industry?

As we get closer to a potential government shut down, I’ve seen several reports on how this will affect the housing market and the mortgage industry. Some of the information is accurate but there are some consequences that have not been mentioned.

The largest impact will be directly to mortgage loans that are being contracted to close during the shutdown. Many new applications will sit stagnant while we wait for congress to come to a resolution. How badly this will affect the housing market will depend heavily on how long the shutdown is. For all the work the government has done to avoid a double-dip housing recession with bailouts and government programs (such as the Making Home Affordable programs) their inability to resolve budget disputes may be the direct cause of another drop in house values. 

WHAT FEDERAL AGENCIES WILL BE AFFECTED AND HOW WILL IT IMPACT THE MARKET?

FHA

Specifically, FHA is getting a lot of attention and rightfully so. FHA has been a savior to the mortgage industry since 2008 at the beginning of the recession providing affordable loans with reasonable credit guidelines. From 2005 through 2007, FHA never represented more than 4.25% of all the home loans originated. In 2010, FHA represented over 19% of all home loans and a whopping 30% of new home sales. These statistics have been published directly by the Department of Urban and Housing Development. FHA will not insure home loans during the shutdown. Lenders may choose in their own discretion to fund the loan and request insurance after the shutdown is over.

VA

As of right now, most reports show that the Department of Veterans Affairs will not be impacted. This is good news for veterans who are currently looking to buy a home.

USDA

The USDA (US Department of Agriculture) insures affordable home loans for rural areas. The USDA will not insure new home loans and I’ve received reports that their automated underwriting engine (Guaranteed Underwriting System) will not operate. This not only halts the funding of some USDA loans, but will prevent lenders from pre-approving buyers for this program. Although USDA represents a much smaller percentage of loans than FHA, this program is hit the hardest of the three. Lenders can still manually underwrite the files but most will require the assurance of USDA’s program to approve a client. This is unfortunate after the government spent months working on a budget to fund the USDA after they ran out of loan funds for a portion of 2010. It does sound like USDA lenders will be able to close loans with a conditional commitment up to 90 days of the commitment, but new applications will not be processed and new prospective buyers won’t be able to get pre-approved. Like FHA, lenders may choose to close the loan and wait for the shutdown to end before sending the loan to the USDA at their own discretion.

IRS

Now, let’s talk about the big entity nobody is talking about when talking mortgages, the IRS (Internal Revenue Services).

Many of you are wondering, “How does the IRS have an effect on the mortgage industry?” There’s many ways the IRS can affect home loans since we use tax documents to verify income, but not in the most obvious way.

Mortgage lenders rely heavily on tax documents to calculate and verify a homebuyer’s income. Most homeowners will have their tax documents on hand, but the mortgage industry needs more than a copy of the documents.

Prior to the mortgage meltdown, mortgage lenders trusted their consumers that the tax documents they received were accurate and complete. Lender guidelines have since changed. To avoid fraud and also catch amended tax returns, mortgage guidelines require verification from the IRS that the tax documents the lender has reviewed were accurate and complete. These verifications are done by tax transcripts ordered by the lender to the IRS. You can read more about why transcripts are required here.

Lenders are now requiring transcripts on virtually all loans being processed. Specifically, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac require transcripts for every loan file. I’ve found some reports that state Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will remain operational, indicating that consumers can obtain a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac conventional home loans with no issues. That is only partially true. If the government were to shut down, any consumer who’s applying for a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan will not be able to close on a loan unless the lender had already verified the tax transcripts with the IRS. Any Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan not including transcripts cannot be closed.

This is an issue that appears to be overlooked and will have a larger impact than many have considered. Yes, FHA will have a huge impact, but adding Fannie and Freddie to the mix is a whole different story. According to Fannie Mae, they are the largest issuer of mortgage related securities in the second market representing 44% of the marketplace in 2010.

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac represent more than 60% of the home loans originated today, plus FHA represents over 15%. Not including USDA loans, those three entities already represent more than 75% of all home loan issued today. If gone unnoticed, this government shutdown will have a much larger impact than many are expecting.

Do I think this will destroy the housing market? Honestly, I don’t. At one point, the government will realize the size of this impact and implement some type of action plan. I just hope this is noticed before there’s a government shutdown, not after.

TIPS FOR HOMEOWNERS:

Here are a list of items I would recommend be completed based on the type of loan you’re looking to close.

ALL LOANS

· Order your tax transcripts immediately.

· I haven’t been able to find exact details, but I would order any outstanding flood certifications if you haven’t determined if the property is in a flood zone.

FHA

· FHA Connection will still be up to order case numbers but CAIVRS (a program that does a background check on all parties involved in the transaction)will be down, so have your lender order your CAIVRS Reports right away.

USDA

· USDA will only insure loan commitments already issued (90 day expiration). If you still have time, try to get your commitment approved prior to the shutdown.

· GUS will not be operational, so all buyers looking to get pre-approved on USDA should process their pre-approval right away and new loans should be ran through GUS if they haven’t been done yet.

Page 2 of 1912345678910111213...Last »